14 Worst Rated North American Potato Dishes

Last updated on May 21, 2026
01

Potatoes O'Brien

2.9 ·

Potatoes O'Brien is an American dish consisting of pan-fried potatoes, green bell peppers, and red bell peppers. There is a variation of the dish with crispy bacon added into it for extra flavor and texture. The dish is traditionally served hot as a side to meat dishes. Although the origin of potatoes O'Brien is still murky, some claim that it was invented in a Boston restaurant called Jerome's, while others claim it was invented in a Manhattan restaurant called Jack's. All that is known is that the dish was created in the early 1900s.

02

Pommes de terre soufflées

3.2 ·

Soufflé potatoes is an interesting French creation that is made by double-frying potato slices in very hot oil. The potatoes are thinly sliced into uniform slices, then thoroughly dried before being fried. Once fried, the potato slices are removed from the oil and allowed to chill before being fried for a second time in even hotter oil until puffed up, crispy, and golden brown. The traditional accompanying condiment of choice is sauce béarnaise, which is a combination of butter, egg yolks, lemon, and tarragon. This dish is considered an unforeseen culinary invention from the early 19th century that has been attributed to a certain chef named Collinet. Nowadays, it's also a staple of a few restaurants in New Orleans, Louisiana.

03

Disco Fries

3.3 ·

Disco fries is an American side dish consisting of thick cut steak fries that are layered with brown gravy and mozzarella cheese, which can sometimes be replaced with grated American cheese. It is believed that this tasty side dish was inspired by the famous Canadian poutine. Some claim it was invented in the 1970s after a night out in the disco, while others say it only started to appear in the 1990s. Disco fries are still regularly served in New Jersey eateries, and the dish remains popular with tipsy club goers.

04

Tacos de papa

3.3 ·

Tacos de papa is a variety of Mexican tacos, stuffed with cumin-spiced potatoes. The tacos are fried until they become crispy and develop a golden brown color. Before consumption, there is a plethora of ingredients to use as toppings: onions, salsa, tomatoes, hot chile peppers, or cheese, although the variations are virtually infinite. In Mexico, potato tacos are usually consumed for dinner or during Lent.

05

Salt Potatoes

3.7 ·

Salt potatoes are an iconic side dish coming from the city of Syracuse, New York. The dish is usually served in the summer, when the young potatoes are freshly harvested. The story of salt potatoes starts in the late 1800s, when salt was distilled by boiling water from marshes around the city (Syracuse is well known for its long history of salt production). As there was a large number of Irish workers in the salt springs, they would put the potatoes in the boiling vats and enjoy the meal. There is an organoleptic difference between salt potatoes and regular boiled potatoes - as they cook, salt potatoes develop a crust on the skin which seals them due to the salty boiling water, resulting in a unique, creamy texture once cooked. The dish is often served at clambakes and fairs, traditionally accompanied by a hefty amount of butter, used as a dip. It is also common to buy big packaged bags of salt potatoes, where the producers put the right amount of salt into the bags, making it easier for the home cook to determine the correct ratio of salt and potatoes.

06

Home Fries

3.7 ·

Home fries is a popular American side dish made by frying larger chunks of potatoes in butter or oil until they are crispy and golden in color. The potatoes might sometimes be unpeeled, and they are often shortly boiled or steamed before frying. Home fries are often paired with onions and peppers in the same pan. The dish can be consumed on its own with some salt as a snack, or as a crispy breakfast accompaniment.

07

Sweet Potato Pie

3.7 ·

Sweet potato pie is a traditional pie with origins in the southern parts of the United States of America, and it's especially popular in North Carolina. The dessert is prepared as an open pie without the top crust; its interior usually filled a combination of milk, eggs, sugar, and mashed sweet potatoes. It is often flavored with spices such as vanilla or nutmeg in the South, while in the North, some like to top the pie with marshmallow pieces. The tradition of making sweet potato pie in the South has been present since the days of slavery, and African slaves were the first ones to make the dish. First recipes for the pie started appearing in cookbooks from the 18th century onwards. Since the slaves made the pie for celebrations, communal gatherings, and large family meals, that tradition has continued up to this day, and it is commonly prepared for Thanksgiving in the American South.

08

Poutine râpée

3.7 ·

Poutine râpée is a traditional Acadian dish consisting of a boiled potato dumpling that is stuffed with salted pork. The dumplings can be made from grated or mashed potatoes, and they typically have a greyish color and bland flavor. There are a few ways to consume these dumplings: plain, sprinkled with pepper, white sugar, brown sugar, or even molasses. The dish is usually prepared for special and festive occasions such as Christmas.

09

Chili Cheese Fries

3.8 ·

Chili cheese fries is an American dish with elusive origins. The dish consists of french fries that are topped with chili and grated cheese. There are many origin stories connected with chili cheese fries, although none of them can be 100% confirmed. Texans claim that a 16-year-old Don A. Jenkins invented the dish when he was eating lunch at the local Dairy Queen in Tomball, Texas. In Michigan, it is believed that the dish was invented by two local waitresses who simply combined the ingredients. There are similar stories in New York, Philadelphia, Chicago, and Missouri, but all that is known is that chili cheese fries could be bought in frozen form as early as 1975.

10

Potato Skins

3.8 ·

Potato skins are simple American appetizers consisting of unpeeled potato halves that have been hollowed out, deep-fried, then topped with cheese, bacon, or sour cream. They were originally invented as a way to turn potato peels into a profitable meal. Depending on who you ask, there are three restaurants credited with the invention of this popular appetizer in the 1970s: R.J.Grunts in Chicago, TGI Fridays restaurant chain, or the Prime Rib restaurant in Washington, DC. Today, potato skins are a staple of bar food and come in numerous versions, and there is even a fancy version of the appetizer with crabmeat, hollandaise sauce, and asparagus.

Read more
View all
View map
About this ranking

TasteAtlas food rankings are based on the ratings of the TasteAtlas audience, with a series of mechanisms that recognize real users and that ignore bot, nationalist or local patriotic ratings, and give additional value to the ratings of users that the system recognizes as knowledgeable. For the “14 Worst Rated North American Potato Dishes” list until May 21, 2026, 1,939 ratings were recorded, of which 1,654 were recognized by the system as legitimate. TasteAtlas Rankings should not be seen as the final global conclusion about food. Their purpose is to promote excellent local foods, instill pride in traditional dishes, and arouse curiosity about dishes you haven’t tried.

Similar lists